Things I Learned From Re-Watching the LOTR Trilogy This Weekend:
(Spoilers Ahoy)
- Pippin is a piece of shit. He ruins EVERYTHING. First he starts the fire on Weathertop that attracts the Nazgul and gets Frodo stabbed. Then he disturbs the waters in front of the mines of Moria which upsets the Octopus thing that forces them inside. Then, while in Moria, he knocks a skeleton down a well and attracts the forces of Mordor. Idiot…
- Peter Jackson doesn’t know how to end a movie. He does a full fade to black at a fine ending point… while there’s still 30 minutes left. Then five minutes later, at another perfectly acceptable stopping point, he does ANOTHER fade to black. Then, he does a full fade to white at the ideal ending place… but there’s still ten minutes left! Never fade to black or white unless it’s all over. Rule number one. Would it kill him to try a cross dissolve?
- The conclusion of the Battle at Minas Tirith still bugs the hell out of me and leaves a bad taste in my mouth regarding the entire saga. All films considered, this is a 9.5 hour story being told. And with only two hours left we are introduced to a troop of ghost pirates that owe Gondor a favor.
The entire series has led to this battle, and what happens? It is the cheapest victory in history. They sweep over the battlefield like a green mist, striking their enemies… but not being able to be struck down.
Let me reiterate that point, because it’s the one aspect that really bothers me: they’re INVINCIBLE.
If Aragorn asked them to fulfill their oath and then they transformed back to their former selves and became an extra set of soldiers that helped even the fight and eventually they overcame the forces of Mordor: I approve.
But instead, everybody that fought and died up to this point have done so in vain. And everything leading up to this moment (all 7.5 hours of storytelling mind you) seems silly and trivial because, no worries, we have a force of invincible ghost pirates who will take care of this whole ‘Army of Mordor’ thing for us in 30 seconds flat. It’s such bullshit. I am infuriated right now just typing this.
And if you’ve read the books (which I have not) please don’t immediately get up in arms because they lay the groundwork for this conclusion more so in the novels.
I don’t care.
A movie must be judged as its own, stand-alone product. And even if that’s how it happens in the book, that doesn’t excuse it. That doesn’t make it any less lazy or cheap. Whether I saw it happen on a screen or read it happen in a book, my feelings remain the same.
Regardless of the intellectual property, I hate when people shrug off faults by saying, “well, that’s how it was in the book.” Ooooh, really? Okay, then I guess that makes everything peachy. Wrong! Stupid is stupid, regardless of the medium.
/Rant