I’ve been on a big NASA kick lately and that means I’ve been watching a lot of Apollo mission documentaries.
Before I break them down, one thing to note is how few of these actually have Neil Armstrong in them. It appears he doesn’t grant many interviews.
I suppose he’s too busy being the man than to answer questions about being the man.
Here’s a quick rundown of my findings:
When We Left Earth - This Discovery Channel series (available for streaming on Netflix) is the most enjoyable NASA series I’ve discovered thus far. It includes fantastic, up-converted archival footage, Gary Sinise narration and the most comprehensive collection of interviewees (including Dr. Armstrong). The only gripe I could make is that I wish it was even more detailed than it is. It’s certainly well-paced, but it leaves me wanting more. If you only watch one of the shows on this list, this is the one.
For All Mankind - While ‘When We Left Earth’ is the best series about NASA, if you are more interested in a singular experience, this is the best one out there. This feature length documentary about Apollo includes some phenomenal archival footage that is beautifully restored and the best interviews around (minus Armstrong). Also available on Netflix, I highly recommend this one. Its got the most bang for your buck in a single sitting.
In The Shadow Of The Moon - First hand accounts of the landings are the focus of this film, which is told entirely through interviews with the astronauts themselves (excluding Armstrong). There are some great stories here and it’s covered well with the usual footage, but it’s not as technically interesting as some other shows out there. Though it definitely has the human interest piece of things covered.
The Wonder Of It All - Another astronaut-interview-driven special (without, you guessed it, Neil Armstrong), this one does have some anecdotes you won’t hear anywhere else, but it’s fairly forgettable. Also, the settings for the interviews are atrocious.
Moonshot - This History Channel docudrama is a pretty enjoyable recreation of the Apollo 11 mission. It takes a little dramatic license and retells the events leading up to the mission, as well as the mission itself, in a made-for-TV movie format. The acting is actually pretty good and the patches they fill in with archival footage are clever. But don’t make this the first or only special you watch. You’ll derive more enjoyment from this the more familiar you are with the real life personalities involved.
Magnificent Desolation - Made specifically for IMAX theaters, this special is narrated by Tom Hanks and is aimed mostly at a PG audience. Honestly, it’s mostly kids’ stuff. The recreation of the moon landing is not as well handled as ‘Moonshot,’ and it’s really not worth your time.
Apollo 11: Men on the Moon - The most straight forward of the bunch, this multi-disc special includes all the footage of the take off, landing and EVA… in real time. This special just is that footage. They spice it up a bit by adding multiple angle options and, my favorite, multiple audio tracks. You can watch all 20 minutes of the descent and landing on the moon’s surface while listening to either capsule communication, the flight director talking to his controllers, the press etc. Just hit the audio button on your DVD player and cycle between them. While watching all 2.5+ hours of EVA you can cycle between multiple camera angles or just do a split screen. It’s pretty neat, though obviously a long commitment. (But that’s why there’s the ability to fast-forward.)